Sunday, May 31, 2009

Miroslav Volf and David Martin



Credits to Sivin for this engaging video.

"Professor Miroslav Volf sits down with David Martin, Emeritus Professor of Sociology at the London School of Economics, to discuss the state of faiths in the world today and whether the "secularization thesis" is proving accurate."

Friday, May 29, 2009

Abide with Me

Dalam Alkitab tertulis begini, "Manusia yang pertama, yakni Adam, menjadi makhluk yang hidup," tetapi Adam yang terakhir adalah Roh yang memberi kehidupan.

Yang datang terlebih dahulu adalah yang jasmani, bukan yang rohani. Yang rohani datang kemudian. Adam yang pertama dijadikan dari tanah, tetapi Adam yang kedua berasal dari surga.

Orang-orang dunia ini adalah seperti Adam yang pertama, yang dijadikan dari tanah, tetapi orang-orang surga adalah seperti Dia yang datang dari surga. Sebagaimana kita sekarang adalah seperti Adam yang dijadikan dari tanah, maka nanti kita akan menjadi seperti Dia yang dari surga itu.

Maksud saya, Saudara-saudara, ialah: tubuh yang dijadikan dari darah dan daging, tidak dapat masuk Dunia Baru Allah; dan tubuh yang dapat mati tidak dapat menjadi abadi. Perhatikanlah rahsia ini: Tidak semuanya kita akan mati, tetapi kita semuanya akan berubah.

Hal itu akan terjadi tiba-tiba dalam sekejap mata, pada waktu trompet dibunyikan untuk terakhir kalinya. Sebab pada waktu terdengar bunyi trompet itu, orang-orang mati akan dihidupkan kembali dengan tubuh yang abadi, dan kita semuanya akan diubah. Tubuh kita yang dapat mati ini harus diganti dengan tubuh yang tidak dapat mati, dan tubuh yang dari dunia harus diganti dengan tubuh yang dari surga.

Kalau tubuh yang dapat mati sudah diganti dengan tubuh yang tidak dapat mati, dan tubuh yang dari dunia sudah diganti dengan tubuh yang dari surga, pada waktu itu barulah terjadi apa yang tertulis dalam Alkitab, "Kematian sudah dibasmi; kemenangan sudah tercapai!"

"Hai maut, di manakah kemenanganmu? Hai maut, di manakah bisamu?"

(1Co 15:45-55)

Semoga Berjumpa Lagi, Uncle Lui

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

May 13 Forum

Monday, May 18, 2009

Medical Education in Malaysia : A reflection

Everyone wants to be doctor

Every year we hear about many students applying for medical schools and scholarships through various means. The government, being the major provider of medical education through public medical schools and overseas scholarships, is usually put at fault when high achieving students fail in their application into state-funded medical education for various reasons. These high achieving students often lament that their peers with lower academic credentials are given advantage over them due to the affirmative action policies of the government.

While no government in the world can guarantee public medical education for every aspiring student, a pro-affirmative policy will definitely reduce the chances of non-beneficiaries obtaining a place in a state-funded program. One therefore has to increase one’s chances of scoring a place through an arbitrary selection process, based on rough guidelines such as the following:

a) Do outstandingly well not only to qualify for public medical school, but superiorly, at the top of the class and region;

b) Exhibit strong leadership qualities and special skills through involvement in co-curricular activities at state and national levels;

c) Possess flawless communication skills in Malay and English in a collegial setting;

d) Be able to articulate opinions on various socioeconomic and political issues, besides showing appreciation of local culture and norms;

e) Have access to some well-known political parties and figures to support one’s application.

Thus, for the average student who does not benefit from affirmative action, it is very challenging to gain a place in state-funded programs. However, they have a reason to rejoice with the recent liberalization of private education in Malaysia in the last decade. Many aspiring students who failed a place in the public sector may be able to pursue medical education and career inside and outside the country. It is a popular career choice for many Malaysians of all ethnicities, as a medical career does not only promise social mobility but also a stable income and social prestige. With greater affluence and increasing accessibility for private medical education through various twinning and private programs, the demand has increased dramatically.

More medical schools are opened not only by private institutions, but by state-owned institutions as well. The overwhelming popularity of medical education has been exemplified by the opening of various colleges, including ones which are dubious. State governments lobby for the opening of medical school campuses, medical schools are used as political and economic tools to reward different regional communities, like the recently Terengganu state university. Newer urban communities aspire to have the prestige of a medical school like the Cyberjaya, Iskandar Developmental Region and Kuala Lumpur Education City. To meet the fierce demand for medical education insufficiently provided by domestic providers, state scholarships seek not only to fund medical education for students from traditional providers like the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India and Egypt, but also lesser known and somewhat questionable ones like Indonesian, Ukrainian, Russian, Czech and Polish institutions.

Sustainability

I am no economist. But I have a deep nagging fear that the Malaysian health system may not be able to absorb a steady stream of fresh medical graduates into the workforce. Health workers are not mass-produced workers for the system, but they are more of apprentices who require ongoing training and supervision from their seniors. Would they therefore gain adequate and appropriate post-graduate medical education?

Beside, with a health budget of RM8.7 billion (from 2006 figures), 6.33% of the national budget, health spending per capita is a meagre RM327. I wonder whether the government would be able to consistently increase its spending on healthcare to employ more doctors annually, not considering those who are already underpaid and overworked. With an increasing influx of graduates, would we be able to pay our doctors reasonably comparative to other developing countries, and would we be able to provide adequate ongoing training and supervision? The thought of the Phillipines, where doctors have to go overseas as nurses haunt my dreams.

With the proliferation of private healthcare providers due to a poorly coordinated dual health system, leeching off public medical consultants and medical officers, are we seeing junior doctors bloating our underinvested public health institutions, providing less than optimal care to our populace?

The justification for excessive and unsustainable training of medical students is the shortage of medical staff, repeated often by government officials and ministers of health. Tun Dr Mahathir’s ambitious Vision 2020 with a doctor-populace ration of 1:500 has perhaps driven the craze for the mass-production of medical graduates to achieve a so-called “developed nation status”. But to aspire for such unrealistic figure within a short time without proportionate increase in GDP per capita healthcare spending comparative to other OECD, is perhaps an exercise of self-delusion. Without an economy resilient and strong enough to support an extensive health system, a hyperinflated model of healthcare would mean few things; underpaid, overworked and undertrained staff.

Cheap measures to prevent these underpaid and overworked staff namely by bonding them with an almost-lifetime bond of 10 years (for basic training) and another 8 years (for postgraduate training) may work in the short term to prevent them from escaping the system that treats them with equal dignity with a factory machine. But until and unless there are systemic reforms in the public healthcare funding, recruitment and delivery of service, we are deluding ourselves of a “developed status healthcare” boasting only of our holy ratio of 1:500, but unable to deliver a system that effectively engages with the health of the nation. We will only be able to boast of thousands of health slaves providing for the people, but we may not be able to deliver a system that is well-funded, well-equipped, well-trained, well-coordinated and well-delivered to the people. Our noble intentions of serving the people would bear no fruit, as we may lose public confidence in the long run due to suboptimal services.

Thus, a brave systemic reform in Malaysia is sorely needed.

One School For All


Satu bangsa satu bahasa
Malaysia berjaya!

Friday, May 15, 2009

JPA Scholarships

The controversy regarding the JPA scholarship has emerged again, with a few alleged top scorers complaining of not getting overseas scholarship despite getting more A1s. From my limited knowledge, they were given a local scholarship instead. They were upset that their peers who obtained less A1s were given an overseas scholarship. Without knowing whether they are applying for the same course (note that medical scholarships have higher academic requirements than other courses) or whether the SPM subjects that they took correlates with the course that they are applying for, we can’t make any conclusion and therefore place our trust in our beloved champions of our respective races (be it MCA, DAP or MIC), ironically in the midst of a new political climate.

The JPA scholarship is indeed a prized scholarship within the medium to lower class non-bumiputera students who aspire for an overseas education. Since the cap on SPM subjects has been taken away in 2000, more students are taking more subjects in order to improve their chances of scoring as many A1s as possible to secure that scholarship. Like myself, many of them do not know that other scholarships and financial assistance do exist to help them further their studies elsewhere.

Many of them like myself many years ago, may have not been exposed to academia well enough to appreciate the wide variety of undergraduate courses available, be it of liberal arts or the sciences. We were just told by our teachers, parents, seniors and friends that the only way to go is JPA. And the only way to get it is to eat our Pelangi textbooks and regurgitate them out into the exam paper, besides going for tuition classes for every subjects that we are taking from the best tutors in town (nevermind that they suck in teaching at school).

It is also interesting that there is a growing sense of entitlement for those scholarships, with many claiming that they deserve that scholarship. Not any type of scholarship but an overseas scholarship for their many A1s, regardless of their co-curricular achievement, communication skills or socioeconomic background. This is particularly reflected in Sdr. Lim Kit Siang’s call for automatic grants for students achieving 9A1s and above. “Why must deserving students BEG for scholarships?” our politicians lament.

While it is probably a political suicide not to harp this issue among the non-bumiputera community, I feel that it is a bit too much to promote a sense of entitlement. The very people who are championing the removal of some special rights, are the very people who are advocating a new form of rights; “the Special Rights of 9A1s”. This right should be served by the nation by drawing upon the almost unending national reserves, regardless of the economic crisis nor pure common sense. As long as these rights are served and the money invested on tuition classes brings returns, anything goes.

Without putting a check, an unhealthy sense of entitlement may justify the removal of the 20% allocation for Sabah and Sarawak students and students with special needs, who may not necessarily meet the 9A1 mark to be entitled for this right. Perhaps students whose parents earn less than RM1500, who can barely afford to gain 10A1 may have to give way for their peers who get 13A1s, 14A1s, 15A1s or more, in the ever increasing competition to fight for the limited number of scholarships, all in the name of the Holy Meritocracy. With the trend of increasing A1s, thanks to the rat-race kiasu mentality of some urban middle-class Malaysians, the poor and the disadvantaged may be marginalised.

Who cares for the poor and disadvantaged? They are lazy and too bad they have learning difficulties, says some. Personal responsibility and hard work is the key to success, and certainly the passport to gain the “Special rights of the 9A1”. The survival of the fittest is the way to go, who cares about bad genes, post-colonial displacement, socioeconomic disparity, urban-rural divide and unequal opportunities?

Living Fully Until We Die

"The modern hospice movement is rooted in a much older idea of hospitality. Indeed, the term comes from the same Latin root as hospital and hostel. Places of hospitality were not confined to the Latin-speaking world, however. Greeks, Indians, Romans, early Christians, and Muslims all built places where pilgrims and travelers, particularly the sick, could rest and find care. In modern times, Christians showed their commitment to hospitality for the hurting by building hospitals and, at the end of the 19th century, the first institutions dedicated solely to caring for the dying. Called hospices, these institutions lacked the fully formed philosophy that would characterize the modern movement, they but did offer inspiration to the movement's founder, Dame Cicely Saunders.

Saunders established the first modern hospice, St. Christopher's, in 1967. Located in London, St. Christopher's was the result of Saunders' experience treating dying people, her belief that people could flourish even as they died, and her sense of Christian call..."

"Saunders also used St. Christopher's to show how religion could be integrated into the experience of dying. Her hospice was open to Christians and non-Christians alike but had, she said, a Christian foundation. She also claimed that treating physical pain gave patients freedom—a freedom she saw them use "in time for family reconciliations, in deepening relationships, and in all the sorting out of beliefs and memories that can help others say, with Pope John XXIII, 'My bags are packed—I can go with a tranquil heart at any moment.'"

Even after her retirement in 1985, Saunders actively promoted her movement as well as her beliefs about the intersection of faith and dying. She strongly condemned euthanasia. Hospice, according to Saunders, encouraged people to live fully until they died. Convinced that with modern drugs people need not die in pain, she claimed that euthanasia precluded the work of a good death—the reconciliation with mortality, with family, and with God that occurred as people died. "It is not for us to say that the suffering is fruitless," she wrote, "nor that there is nothing more for the patient to do or learn in this life." People were not the own masters, she claimed."

Sarah Johntone for Christianity Today

Thursday, April 02, 2009

He Waiata o Hemi'

He Waiata o Hemi
I came to Hiruharama (Jerusalem)
With a leather coat;
Now the coat is cloth (your gift/loan)
but the cuffs are still leather. (voluntary poverty)

Kua timata te mahi –
The work has begun.
There are beans growing
And Karl planted them;
There are pumpkins growing
And Heto dug the ground;
There are eels in the pot
And Peter caught them – Yes,
Kua timata te mahi–
The work has begun.

Ka whakaiti taku mana,
Ka whakanui te aroha –

As I shrink down to death
The love will grow greater.
The old kumara has to rot
For the young ones to get life –
When the hangi is ready (feast)
They dig them out of the ground,
The young ones red and strong,
but the old one is pulpy –
They throw him over the fence
With mildew round his neck. (kenosis)


He parapara iti,
The little seed in the ground
The all-but-nothing thing –
The soul that sleeps naked
In the arms of Te Atua – (God)
No good at all if the seed
Was wrapped in cellophane. (no possessions)

Because our God is dark
The blindness does not matter –
Because our God is silent
The deaf man gets no blame.

What can I do in the morning?
I can put on my coat;
I can make a cup of coffee;
And light a cigarette;
I can kneel down like a camel
On the grass beside the fence;
I can eat and walk and sleep;
I can pray for those I love –
Ko te aroha, i te Ariki –
When we love, it is the Lord –
And this dead man is permitted
To give with empty hands.

When we share our fags and blankets
Christ begins to shine –
Our flesh becomes the bread;
Our blood becomes the wine –
I am cowshit in the garden
So that the crops can grow –
Ko Ihu taku wai,
The Lord is my drink –
Ko Ihu taku kai,
The Lord is my food –
Ko Ihu taku moni,
The lord is my bank account –
Ko Ihu taku mana,
The Lord is my good name –
Ko Ihu taku aroha,
The Lord is my heart –
Ko Ihu taku mate,
The Lord is my death pain.

To be a dead goat
That the flies gather on –
The sun in his mercy
Can make the teeth shine.
Even our sins are His (He ‘became sin’ for us)
Let the new pain begin.

Arohanui, e pa.
Hemi

James K Baxter

Monday, March 23, 2009

10 Ideas That Is Changing the World Right Now


Times Magazine mentioned that the New Calvinism is one of the coolest things in the world right now. I wonder how would John Calvin in heaven, respond to this article, together with contemporaries.
Mark Driscoll suggested a helpful comparison between the Old and the New Calvinism, stating why is it so powerful.
  1. Old Calvinism was fundamental or liberal and separated from or syncretized with culture. New Calvinism is missional and seeks to create and redeem culture.
  2. Old Calvinism fled from the cities. New Calvinism is flooding into cities.
  3. Old Calvinism was cessationistic and fearful of the presence and power of the Holy Spirit. New Calvinism is continuationist and joyful in the presence and power of the Holy Spirit.
  4. Old Calvinism was fearful and suspicious of other Christians and burned bridges. New Calvinism loves all Christians and builds bridges between them.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Batu Penjuru Gereja


The Church's one foundation
is Jesus Christ her Lord;
she is his new creation,
by water and the word:
from heaven he came and sought her
to be his holy bride;
with his own blood he bought her,
and for her life he died.

Batu penjuru G’reja dan Dasar yang esa,
yaitu Yesus Kristus, Pendiri umatNya.
Dengan kurban darah-Nya Gereja ditebus;
baptisan dan firman-Nya membuatNya kudus.


Elect from every nation,
yet one o'er all the earth,
her charter of salvation,
one Lord, one faith, one birth;
one holy Name she blesses,
partakes one holy food,
and to one hope she presses,
with every grace endued.

Terpanggil dari bangsa seluruh dunia,
bertunggallah Gereja bertuhan Yang Esa.
Melimpah kurnia-Nya, esa baptisan-Nya,
esa perjamuan-Nya, esa harapan-Nya.

Though with a scornful wonder
men see her sore oppressed,
by schisms rent asunder,
by heresies distressed;
yet saints their watch are keeping,
their cry goes up, "How long?"
and soon the night of weeping
shall be the morn of song.

Dilanda perpecahan dan faham yang sesat.
Jemaat diresahkan tekanan yang berat.
Kaum kudus menyerukan, “Berapa lamakah?”
Akhirnya malam duka diganti terang cerah.


Mid toil and tribulation,
and tumult of her war
she waits the consummation
of peace for evermore;
till with the vision glorious
her longing eyes are blessed,
and the great Church victorious
shall be the Church at rest.

Di dalam pencobaan dan perjuangannya
dinantikan zaman sejahtera baka.
Di mata tercerminkan Gereja yang menang
mencapai perhentian sentosa cemerlang.

Yet she on earth hath union
with God, the Three in one,
and mystic sweet communion
with those whose rest is won.
O happy ones and holy!
Lord, give us grace that we
like them, the meek and lowly,
on high may dwell with thee.

Gereja yang di sorga dan yang di dunia
bersatu dalam Tuhan, Ketiga Yang Esa
Ya Tuhan, b’ri anug’rah supaya kami pun
Engkau tempatkan juga kekal dirumah-Mu.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Christians are (can be) the best Malaysians

1. We are called to be peace-makers, commanded by Jesus. We condemn war, persecution and injustice, in the Holy Land together with our Muslim cousins.

2. We care for the poor and downtrodden, disabled and orphaned. We provided for the needy and fought for social justice. We affirm the national affirmative action to eradicate poverty regardless of ethnicity.

3. We are the most ethnically diverse group in Malaysia, with congregations of many different ethnic groups, building bridges with each other. We also have high proportion of interethnic marriages.

4. We are a healed and healing community of Jesus, constantly freed from the sin of bitterness, hatred, anger and distrust as a minority, empowering us to love our neighbors, rulers and participate actively in nation-building.

5. We build bridges between religious groups, standing between the monotheistic official religion and the other non-monotheistic faiths. We empathize both with the role of the official monotheistic religion, in our memory of Constantinople as well as assuming a minority religion in the public square.

6. We pay taxes accordingly to the state, commanded by Scripture. We obey and pray for our Rulers before God. We respect the rule of law and the legal framework of the Constitution, and appreciate our equal democratic and civil rights.

7. We are willing to be sent to distant towns and villages, accepting lower wages and career advancement for the sake of the rakyat. Christians have a sense of calling, many choosing the path of downward mobility.

8. We do not separate the secular and the sacred, thus sharing a vision for a nation build upon religious and moral framework acceptable to all Malaysians. We agree with the first article of the Rukunnegara, that our nation should be God-fearing one.

9. We engage politically on the individual level by exercising our democratic rights and freedoms. Christian politicians of different political leanings, are active in nation-building, faithful to the Christian social vision.

10. We care for the alien as human beings with dignity; legal and illegal. We provide for their needs and ensure their welfare; physical, emotional, social and spiritual. Many immigrant church congregations are formed, serving the needs for the alien.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Doa Untuk Palestin dan Israel.

Konflik di Gaza baru-baru ini perlulah diinsafi oleh kita semua, rakyat Malaysia pelbagai keturunan dan agama. Keganasan terhadap umat manusia dan rakyat yang tertindas bukan hanya isu di kalangan umat Islam, tetapi isu yang menghadapi umat Kristian juga. Dalam hal ini, Cahaya Nusantara membawakan isu tersebut untuk dijadikan doa dan renungan semua.

"Dalam konflik ini, lebih daripada yang lain, keamanan dan keadilan berkait rapat. Penulis Kitab Mazmur menyebut kebenaran/keadilan dan keamanan bersama, “keadilan dan damai sejahtera akan bercium-ciuman.” (Mazmur 85:10). James pula menyebut bahawa, ‘orang yang mempunyai kebijaksanaan yang berasal dari atas, ia pertama-tama sekali murni, kemudian suka berdamai, peramah, dan penurut. Ia penuh dengan belas kasihan dan menghasilkan perbuatan-perbuatan yang baik. Ia tidak memihak dan tidak berpura-pura. Memang kebaikan adalah hasil dari benih damai yang ditabur oleh orang yang cinta damai!’ (Jas 3:17-18)."

Teruskan baca

Sunday, December 28, 2008

Selamat Pengantin Baru


Selamat pengantin baru.
Selamat berbahgia.
Selamat ke anak cucu.
Selamat sejahtera.

Semoga berpanjangan.
Semoga berkekalan.
Semoga satu tujuan.
Semoga aman.

Hidup mestilah rukun.
Sabar paling perlu..
Cinta setiap hari..
Senyum mesti selalu.
-- Saloma

Tahniah Dora atas selamatnya majlis perkahwinan dan akad nikah abang Syazwan dan kakak Zakiah. Semoga senantiasa dicucuri berkat Ilahi sehingga ke anak cucu.

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Magnificat


Lalu kata Maria: "Jiwaku memuliakan Tuhan,
dan hatiku bergembira karena Allah, Juruselamatku,
sebab Ia telah memperhatikan kerendahan hamba-Nya.

Sesungguhnya, mulai dari sekarang
segala keturunan akan menyebut aku berbahagia,
karena Yang Mahakuasa telah
melakukan perbuatan-perbuatan besar kepadaku
dan nama-Nya adalah kudus.

Dan rahmat-Nya turun-temurun atas orang yang takut akan Dia.
Ia memperlihatkan kuasa-Nya dengan perbuatan tangan-Nya
dan mencerai-beraikan orang-orang yang congkak hatinya;

Ia menurunkan orang-orang yang berkuasa dari takhtanya
dan meninggikan orang-orang yang rendah;

Ia melimpahkan segala yang baik kepada orang yang lapar,
dan menyuruh orang yang kaya pergi dengan tangan hampa;

Ia menolong Israel, hamba-Nya,
karena Ia mengingat rahmat-Nya,
seperti yang dijanjikan-Nya kepada nenek moyang kita,
kepada Abraham dan keturunannya untuk selama-lamanya."

(Luk 1:46-55)
Selamat Hari Natal

Monday, December 08, 2008

On Providence


"For God's providence is as plain as the sun and its rays,
in each situation and place, in the wilderness,
in inhabited regions and uninhabited,
on earth or sea or wherever you might go,
you will observe the clear and sufficient,
ancient and new, reminders of this providence"

John Chrysostom of Constatinople
On Providence

Saturday, November 01, 2008

Class of 2008

Finally, half-way more to go!

Monday, October 27, 2008

Labour promises more doctors in training by 2011

Labour is promising 100 extra places in medical schools by 2011, toughened regulation and public audits of aged care facilities.

Prime Minister Helen Clark and Health Minister David Cunliffe released Labour's election health policy today and said it underlined the party's commitment to a strong, safe, affordable and accessible public health system for every New Zealander.

"Labour will continue to invest in a world class public health strategy aimed at helping New Zealanders stay well.

"We will prioritise fighting the disease and disability caused by obesity, tobacco, and alcohol and by the preventable cancers."

Labour's promise to increase the number of doctors in training by 100 by 2011 follows National's pledge of an additional 200 places over five years - which would lead to 140 extra places by 2011.

Announcing the policy today, Helen Clark said Labour said was committed to new initiatives like the B4 school checks for four year-olds, bowel cancer screening and HPV vaccination against causes of cervical cancer.

She said Labour would also introduce free annual health checks for the intellectually disabled with high support needs.

Helen Clark said as soon as economic circumstances permitted it would work to lower the cost of doctor visits further, with priority being given to the 65 plus and six to seventeen year age groups.

Mr Cunliffe said Labour would work with DHBs to strengthen regional, clinical, and administrative networks.

Productivity could be lifted through joint purchasing and common approaches to workforce development and IT planning.

"Labour will also continue to prioritise shorter waiting times for treatment in the cardiac, cancer and orthopaedic services," he said.

"We will also strengthen work force development and regulation in the aged care sector, and ensure that the audits of facilities are publicly available."

- NZPA

Sunday, October 26, 2008

The Parable of the Banquet



If little children aged from 9 months to 13 years old can't access surgical treatments for their hearts in their own homeland, then something must be very very wrong in the Malaysian health system.

It is a paradox where a country that boasts a RM9 billion health budget, the world's top five medical tourism destination with a RM200million industry, 361 public and private hospitals with 47376 beds, and the ever-famous National Heart Institute that houses 85 cardiac specialists under one roof, can barely afford to meet the needs of a mere 17 children.

It is a national shame that we should seek the cheapest option available to fly these children and their families to another country, when there is so much capacity within the private sector to treat our own kin. We prefer to treat the rich, the famous and the foreign but marginalise our own poor and needy. Anak di riba dibiarkan, kera di hutan disusui.

We aspire to be a developed nation with huge investment poured into the many medical schools and medical scholarships annually, yet we barely provide for the needs of the poor. In 2006, there are 13,335 public medical practitioners compared to 8602 private ones, accounting to a ratio of 3:2. This seems reasonable and alright.

But when the medical needs are actually compared, the inequality to access and providence of healthcare is rather shocking. While the MOH health stats do not reveal much information, a rough estimation of doctor:bed ratio, of public and private health sector (30,396 and 11637 beds respectively), is about 1 : 2.3 (1 doctor to 2.3 beds) for public hospitals and 1:1.4 (1 doctor to 1.4 beds). This does not include the amount of doctor : outpatient ratio.

This means that public doctors are actually serving almost double the amount of beds than private doctors. This also implies that the public of all strata of society do not receive comparable proportions of health resources, with the rich enjoying almost double the amount of health resources available, while the poor are grabbing whatever resources left.

Imagine a big banquet with a huge table with luxury food and abundance for the few rich and a small table with rationed soup for the to be shared among the throngs of beggars. After a while, the soup for the poor run out, the poor old beggar and the blind orphan who came late and was hungry was disappointed that the soup has ran out. They begged for the banquet host for more soup, perhaps some of the leftovers or droppings from the table of the rich. Instead, they were turned away, and were sent to go to the pig farm next door, which served leftover food for pigs.

When there isn't enough beds for the poor, when the poor is sent to somewhere else, instead of sharing some of the rich people's beds, when even just a bite from the rich people's table is not possible, then there is something very wrong with the banquet host.

Friday, October 17, 2008

The Only Hope for Monsters

The evils and crimes of the world is certainly no worse than the evil of our own. Perhaps PM-wannabes and crime enforcers should realise that. Read The Only Hope for Monsters

Alex Tang noted a few principles for doctors

Whoever takes up medicine should aeriously consider the following points: firstly, that he must one day render to the Supreme Judge an account of the lives of those sick men who have been entrusted to his care.

Secondly, that such skill and science as, by the blessing of Almighty God, he has attained, are to be specially directed toward the honour of his Maker, and the welfare of his fellow-creatures; since it is a base thing for the great gifts of Heaven to become the servants of avarice and ambition.

Thirdly, he must remember that it is no mean or ignoble animal that he deals with. He may ascertain the worth of the human race, since for its sake God’s Only-begotten Son became man, and thereby ennobled the nature that he took upon him.

Lastly, he must remember that he himself hath no exemption from the common lot, but that he is bound by the same laws of mortality, and liable to the same ailments and afflictions with his fellows. For these and like reasons let him strive to render aid to the distressed with the greater care, with the kindlier spirit, and with the stronger fellow-feeling..

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

Traditional and Complementary Medicine

The Ministry of Health has introduced traditional and complementary medicine in a few public hospitals in Malaysia lately. While it is undoubtedly popular among lay people, the efficacy of the treatment is still in much doubt, and yet to be supported by leading good quality evidence-based research around the world.

It is rather concerning that the Ministry of Health would make choices based on popularity without considering its efficacy and value-for-money especially in improving mortality and morbidity. What more, the precious tax-payers money invested in the health system which is certainly not adequate to provide for the increasing need for primary care nor tertiary medical services, is unnecessarily spent on TCM providers whom may not deal with real biomedical problems.

While I understand that patients have the choice to opt for contemporary or alternative ones, it is preposterous that public funds are used to finance services that are show little or no significant benefit in disease intervention, while there are thousands more who are dying on waiting list for surgeries or cancer treatment. There are many more hospitals and clinics that are underfunded and are lacking in adequate medical equipments, struggling with the RM8 billion budget for health.

This is indeed a contradiction to some of the strategic plan laid out Ministry of Health, namely to
prevent and reduce the burden of disease, enhance the healthcare delivery system and optimise resources (p.9) through health indicators like average life expectancy at birth, crude death rates and infant rates. I don't see how having urut or munching Lidah Jin, or taking jamu Tongkat Ali or Kacip Fatimah, nor the poking needles onto one's biceps could have any effects whatsoever to those indicators. More evidence must be justified by the Ministry to randomly start up things on whim and fancy, rather than succumbing to popular cultural sentiments.